Is a Circle an Egg? Only If You Were Taught So: How to Protect Children's Creative Thinking

Divergent Thinking Doodle

▎The Core Idea — In One Sentence

98% of four-year-olds see infinity in a circle. By adulthood, only 2% remain. Imagination doesn't disappear — the environment replaces it with ready-made answers. To protect imagination, you only need one thing: put an "object without an answer" back in the child's hands.


Draw a Circle. What Is It?

Most adults will answer without thinking: an egg. A coin. A wheel. Something concrete. Something with one name.

Now give that circle to a four-year-old.

The sun. A face. The moon. A button. A burrow. A giant's eye. A planet where only cats live. A bagel hole. A drop that's about to fall.

One circle. Dozens of universes.

This isn't "rich imagination." This is divergent thinking — the ability to see multiple answers where an adult sees just one. Children are born with this ability. But something takes it away along the way.


What Science Says: Creativity Is Not a Talent — It's a Muscle. One That Atrophies.

The most cited experiment in this field was conducted in 1968 by George Land and Beth Jarman — commissioned by NASA to select innovative engineers. They created a divergent thinking test and out of curiosity tested 1,600 children.

The result became a classic:

Age Level of "Creative Genius"
4–5 years 98%
10 years 30%
15 years 12%
Adults less than 2%

But this result is not an isolated finding. Later research confirms the same curve.

In 2011, Professor Kyung Hee Kim at the College of William and Mary published an analysis of Torrance Test scores — the most authoritative tool for measuring creative thinking — over several decades. The conclusion: since 1990, children's creative thinking scores have been steadily declining. Meanwhile, IQ scores rose over the same period.

This isn't genetics. Genes don't change in a single generation. The environment changes.


The Environment That Teaches: "There Is Only One Answer"

A child is born with open perception. A circle is infinite. But the environment quickly explains: a circle has a correct name. Egg. Not a giant's eye. The right answer. The wrong one — crossed out.

Toys do the same thing.

Closed Toy Open Object
A plastic truck with a face, sound, and a button A beech wood block. No face. No button.
Tells the child: "I am a truck. Roll me." Asks: "Who am I? You decide."
One function → in the corner two days later Infinite roles → a truck today, a phone tomorrow, a beetle's throne next month
Child is a recipient Child is a creator

In 1971, architect Simon Nicholson gave this a theoretical foundation: the "Theory of Loose Parts." In any environment, the degree of inventiveness and creativity is directly proportional to the number and variety of variables in it.

Simply put: the less an object dictates, the more a child creates.


Fewer Toys — More Play. In Numbers.

University of Toledo, 2018. 36 children aged 18–30 months. Two conditions: 4 toys, then 16.

4 toys 16 toys
Duration of play with one object Longer (approximately 2x) Shorter
Number of ways to play with one object High — built, banged, fed, hid Low — grabbed, threw, switched
Depth of engagement Immersion Distraction

Researchers' conclusion: fewer toys = higher quality and deeper play.


We Call This "Quiet Expansion"

At Aqyl Mura, when we look at this data, we don't see "children are losing creativity." We see something else —

When a child is not told what to do with an object, their thinking fills the void on its own.

We call this "quiet expansion."

Emptiness. No instructions. No buttons. No "right way to play." The child's neurons are forced to find their own path. The first time — they don't know. The second — they try one direction. The third — it becomes their own path. This isn't imagination. This is the physical construction of neural connections.

An object without an answer is the physical form of this emptiness.

Quiet — because no one is speaking. Expansion — because when the brain is forced to find its own answer, synaptic connection speed is at its maximum.


We Are Aqyl Mura. Why Does a Wooden Learning Brand Write About Circles and Eggs?

Because every day we think about what ends up in a child's hands.

Our first set — "The First 180 Days" for newborns. But our system is built to accompany the child at every stage of growth. Not toys. Development tools.

Every object in our sets is an "object without an answer."

A beech wood ball. For an adult — a ball. For a 4-month-old — something to grasp. At 8 months — something that rolls. At 2 years — the moon in a toy sky. At 4 — a planet.

Not a single object tells the child what it is. Not painted. Not voiced. Doesn't depict a character. It simply exists — real, warm, with a texture you feel with your fingers.

Maria Montessori called the period from birth to 6 years the "absorbent mind." During this time, a child absorbs everything around them without a filter — and builds the foundation of lifelong thinking from it.

An "object without an answer" doesn't ask "can you play." It asks — "what do you see?"


How to Choose What Will Preserve Imagination

Three simple filters.

Filter Question to Ask Yourself Sign of a Good Object
Who's in charge "Who's deciding here — the child or the object?" Object without an answer: the child decides what it is
How many roles "How many different ways can this be used?" The function never ends — one thing today, another tomorrow
Tactile honesty "Do I want to hold this in my own hands for longer than thirty seconds?" Warm, textured, real — you don't want to let go

What to Do This Evening

Open the toy drawer. Take out four objects. Put the rest in a closet for two weeks.

Of those four, keep at least two that don't depict anyone. Just a block. Just a ball. Just fabric.

Tomorrow morning, place them on the floor. Say nothing. Sit nearby.

Watch what happens.


▎Real Questions People Ask Search Engines

Q1: why does a child quickly lose interest in toys

Because the toy has "run out." If it has one function — press a button, it sings — the child exhausts it in five minutes. An open object never runs out: tomorrow it can be something different. University of Toledo data confirms: 4 open objects produce deeper and longer play than 16 closed ones.


Q2: how to develop creativity in a child at home

Don't develop it. Protect it. Creativity is already in the child. The main thing — don't remove it with an environment where every question has one answer. Three steps: fewer toys, more open materials, fewer screens. Kim (2011) showed: creativity declines not from lack of activities, but from an excess of ready-made answers.


Q3: what are open-ended toys — examples

Any objects that don't tell the child what to do with them. Wooden blocks. Simple balls. Fabric scarves. Natural materials. Nicholson's principle (1971): the less an object dictates a script, the more the child creates on their own. A plastic cartoon hero — one role. A beech wood cube — infinitely many.


Q4: at what age can Montessori be started

From birth. The first things that develop — vision and the grasping reflex. Black-and-white cards → a beech wood rattle → a ball to grasp. This isn't a race of early development. It's the right materials at the right moment. Montessori called the period from 0 to 6 years the "absorbent mind" — everything the child sees and touches now builds the foundation of thinking for decades ahead.


Q5: Aqyl Mura — are these toys?

No. We create development tools — a system that starts with a newborn set and accompanies the child through all subsequent stages of growth. Not toys. Tools. Selected for a specific developmental milestone. Every object is an "object without an answer": the same beech wood ball at 4 months is a grasping tool, at 2 years — the moon, at 4 — a planet. The same beech. One philosophy. Different stages.


Q6: how many toys should a child have

Less than you think. The University of Toledo experiment showed: 4 open objects produce deeper play than 16. A practical rule: put away half the toys for two weeks. Then swap them. This isn't poverty. It's respect for the child's ability to concentrate.


▎The Most Important Thing

A circle is not an egg. A circle is infinity.

Your child already knows this. The only question is —

What will you put in front of them tomorrow morning? An object that tells them what to do? Or an object without an answer — that asks: "What do you see?"

Silence. Emptiness. Expansion. That's where all creativity begins.


Aqyl Mura — a development system that starts from the first days and accompanies the child at every stage of growth.


▎Sources

Kim, K. H. (2011). The creativity crisis: The decrease in creative thinking scores on the Torrance Tests of Creative Thinking. Creativity Research Journal, 23(4), 285–295.

Land, G. & Jarman, B. (1992). Breakpoint and Beyond: Mastering the Future Today. HarperCollins.

Dauch, C., Imwalle, M., Ocasio, B., & Metz, A. E. (2018). The influence of the number of toys in the environment on toddlers' play. Infant Behavior and Development, 50, 78–87.

Nicholson, S. (1971). How not to cheat children: The theory of loose parts. Landscape Architecture, 62(1), 30–34.

Montessori, M. (1949). The Absorbent Mind. Theosophical Publishing House.

Lillard, A. S. (2017). Montessori: The Science Behind the Genius (3rd ed.). Oxford University Press.


0 comments

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.